In my last blog post, I discussed the need to closely
examine commercial dog food labels when deciding which brand and specific
product(s) to feed your dog. My leading
recommendation was to select a dog food that contains a protein (meat) as one
of its major ingredients.
In today’s post, I’ll elaborate on this topic as well as
direct your attention to some other items to look for as you evaluate dog food.
A meat (protein) such as chicken, beef or lamb should be
listed as one of the first ingredients.
This reflects the requirement by pet food manufacturers to list
ingredients in order of their weight.
Under most circumstances, products with meat listed in the top 5 are
better choices than those that do not.
This is because the first five ingredients typically make up the
majority of the product, and when a meat is included, the protein content is
apt to be higher.
Try to avoid products that list corn-based ingredients in
the top 5 items. While grains such as
corn and corn meal are often touted by the pet food industry as furnishing
essential energy for a dog, this is not completely accurate. A more precise explanation for their use is
that as carbohydrates, they serve an important role in turning the food into
kibble form. As you might also suspect,
including carbohydrates such as corn is relatively inexpensive. They act as filler calories and for the pet
food manufacturer hold down their production costs.
Be mindful of the sources of protein listed on the
label. Meats and meat by-products do not
necessarily provide the same quality of nutrition. Some meat by-products include items like
hooves, feathers, beaks, eyes, fur, bone and skin (essentially anything
remaining from the butchery); while these are sources of protein, they are not
good sources of protein for your dog.
Finally, if preservatives are present, look for Vitamin E
and/or C as opposed to chemical preservatives. Omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids are also good
ingredients for their anti-inflammatory value and offer protection from kidney
and heart disease. No artificial food
coloring should be present.
In closing, what started as visits to local pet supply
stores in La Jolla to survey the kinds of dog food currently available for
purchase, quickly transformed into a much deeper and meaningful attempt to
understand good canine nutrition. I look
forward to conducting my pet care business and using my blog in ways that go
beyond standard dog walking and pet sitting topics. It’s part of my larger effort to be an
educational resource and advocate of good pet care practices.
David, our dog has lots of allergies so we were feeding him a tremendously expensive food to cover all our bases. Then we found a food at Costco that has none of his allergans in it AND he seems to like it AND it's $20 less a bag than we've been paying. It's a Kirkland brand, Nature's Domain (salmon and sweet potato). I'd love your opinion on it!
ReplyDeleteHi Corrine. Let me do some research on this brand and get back to you.
ReplyDeleteHi Corrine. I looked into the Nature's Domain Salmon and Sweet Potato formula that you are feeding your dog. The first 10 ingredients listed on the packaging tell a positive story. Salmon meal which is a good source of protein is the #1 ingredient (in terms of total weight). This is a gluten-free product so that's why you see ingredients like sweet potatoes and peas, both of which are good sources of fiber. Plus peas contain protein. Ocean fish meal also figures prominently as an ingredient - it is yet another source of protein. And finally, flaxseed is present; it is a source of healthy Omega-3 fatty acids. What you don't see in this dog food are any kind of by-products (that's a good thing). Based upon my reading and analysis, I would say this is a good product. I wouldn't rate it as superb or exceptional, but an overall solid food to give to one's dog.
ReplyDeleteIf you'd like to do some reading of your own, check out Mike Sagman's (aka The Dog Food Advisor) review of Nature's Domain Turkey Meal and Sweet Potato formula. http://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/dog-food-reviews/natures-domain-dog-food/.
While it is not the formula you're feeding your dog, it contains many of the same ingredients and Sagman uses it to represent the larger Nature's Domain line of products. He gives it 3-1/2 stars out of a possible 5. I've read Sagman's reviews on other products; I think he's fair and balanced in reaching a conclusion. And he always has the pet's best interest in mind.
Finally, a quick note about Costco and its lower price for the Salmon & Sweet Potato formula. Good for Costco and good for you! My experience with Costco and its Kirkland house brand is positive - they tend to create very good products with value in mind. Plus given your dog's history of allergies, the fact that the Nature's Domain product is free of all his specific allergens, and he seems to enjoy his mealtime, I say you're on to something. May he lick his bowl with joy!
Thanks for writing me Corrine.
Cheers!
David